Cost Per Call In Healthcare: AI, Outsourced and In-House

Assort Health

AI Built for Specialty Care

November 18, 2026

Back to Blogs

Cost Per Call In Healthcare: AI, Outsourced and In-House

Assort Health

•

November 18, 2026

read

TL;DR

  • Each option puts different costs on the invoice: in-house teams carry payroll and overhead, outsourced partners charge by the hour, minute or call, and AI voice agents charge for usage.
  • Build your own number from payroll, phone reports and contracts instead of borrowing someone else's benchmark.
  • Cost per call is everything your phones cost to run, divided by the calls they handled. Then price each resolved call, since a callback, a redial or a lost patient adds cost.
  • Training, turnover, QA, overages, contract terms and EHR integration work rarely show up on an invoice. They still belong in the total.
Topics
AI in Healthcare
  • Each option puts different costs on the invoice: in-house teams carry payroll and overhead, outsourced partners charge by the hour, minute or call, and AI voice agents charge for usage.
  • Build your own number from payroll, phone reports and contracts instead of borrowing someone else's benchmark.
  • Cost per call is everything your phones cost to run, divided by the calls they handled. Then price each resolved call, since a callback, a redial or a lost patient adds cost.
  • Training, turnover, QA, overages, contract terms and EHR integration work rarely show up on an invoice. They still belong in the total.

The cheapest quote rarely means the cheapest patient call. In-house costs include every staffed minute, supervisor, seat and departure, while outsourced and AI quotes usually price only billed labor or usage. Minimums, setup fees and escalated calls still land back on your team. The fair comparison is cost per resolved call, the price of actually closing a patient's request, and you can build it from your own payroll, phone reports and contracts.

Cost Types to Compare for Each Option

Each option bills for a different slice of the work, so line up the same cost types for all of them before you compare anything.

  • In-house staff: You pay loaded wages, supervision and quality assurance (QA), technology seats, telecom, space and turnover directly. After-hours coverage costs whatever staffing you schedule.
  • Outsourced call center: The hourly or per-agent rate covers billed labor. You still carry contract minimums, setup fees and any follow-up work your staff completes.
  • Answering service: The per-minute or per-call rate covers message-taking or booking, depending on contract scope. You still carry monthly minimums, setup fees, overages and next-day callbacks on every message.
  • AI voice agent: Usage fees cover the calls the agent handles. You still carry the platform subscription, implementation, EHR integration and staff time on every escalated call.

Whichever option you price, the number that matters is total cost divided by the calls each option actually resolves.

Cost Per Call in a Call Center Explained

Call center cost per call is the total cost of running your phone operation for a period, divided by the calls it handled in that period. Some benchmarks report the same measure as cost per contact, a term that can also cover chat and email. BenchmarkPortal's benchmark definition includes all costs of running the center in the numerator. Its denominator includes calls handled by agents and calls handled by technology such as an interactive voice response (IVR) system.

HFMA's call center guidance lists what belongs in the numerator:

  • Agent wages and benefits.
  • Recruiting and training, including turnover.
  • Management.
  • The technology platform and telecom fees.
  • Real estate and overhead.

For outsourced models, the partner's fee is added to any costs you still carry in-house. The same guidance notes that many health systems calculate cost per minute instead. You can convert between the two by dividing cost per call by average handle time.

How to Calculate Cost Per Call for Your Practice

You can build your own number from a few inputs and a one-page worksheet. This section covers the formula, then the cost blocks and inputs, then worked examples at three practice sizes.

The Cost Per Call Formula

Cost per call = (loaded labor + supervision and quality assurance + technology and telecom + space + turnover) ÷ calls handled.

The denominator matters more than most teams expect. Calls offered include every call that rang in. Calls handled exclude the ones that abandoned in the queue.

Suppose a practice spends $90,000 a month, receives 10,000 calls and loses 10% to abandonment:

  • Dividing by calls offered gives $9.00 per call.
  • Dividing by the 9,000 calls handled gives $10.00.

Use calls handled, report abandonment as its own metric, and count calls an AI agent completes as handled.

Fixed vs. Variable Costs

Each cost behaves differently as volume moves. That's why the same practice can post a different cost per call in January and July.

  • Labor: Headcount is fixed in the short run. You pay scheduled staff whether the phones ring or not, so a slow week raises cost per call.
  • Wages and benefits: Benefits add to every paid hour. For office and administrative support occupations, BLS compensation data put benefits at 33.5% of total compensation. That makes loaded cost about 1.50 times the wage.
  • Space: Desks, square footage and furnishings are fixed per seat. Remote agents shift this cost without eliminating it.
  • Technology: Per-seat licenses behave as fixed costs. Per-minute telecom and AI usage scale with volume.
  • Call complexity: Longer calls consume more agent minutes. Multi-request calls, insurance questions and referral scheduling push variable cost up, even when volume stays flat.

The Inputs That Drive Your Number

Six inputs move the result most. Pull each one from your phone reports and payroll before you compare any quote.

  • Monthly call volume: Count calls handled, not calls offered. Volume is the denominator for everything else.
  • Average handle time (AHT): Include talk, hold and after-call work. A 4-minute scheduling call and a 7-minute registration call need very different staffing.
  • Loaded wages: Start from your payroll rate. The BLS median for receptionists working in healthcare and social assistance is $19.00 an hour, before benefits.
  • Abandonment rate: Track this separately from cost. Veterans Health Administration primary care call centers target below 5%.
  • After-hours coverage: Decide whether evenings and weekends end in bookings or messages. When After-hours demand goes to voicemail, staff must return those calls the next day.
  • Value of a missed call: Estimate what an unbooked slot is worth. MGMA's scheduling example uses an average slot value of $125.

Worked Examples at Three Practice Sizes

The worksheet below applies the formula to an in-house team. It assumes 30 inbound calls per front desk employee per day, the level MGMA DataDive data show for primary care staff. Across 21 workdays, that's 630 calls per full-time equivalent (FTE) each month.

Loaded labor is $19.00 × 1.50 = $28.50 an hour. Multiplied by 173.3 paid hours, that comes to $4,940 per FTE-month.

The remaining lines use illustrative assumptions. Replace them with your own figures:

  • Technology at $150 per seat.
  • Space at $250 per seat.
  • Supervision at 10% of labor.
  • Turnover at 40%, matching the 40% front office support staff turnover MGMA reported for 2022. Each departure costs $10,000, the low end of the general employee replacement cost estimate HFMA cites. Each departure requires hiring and training on the same booking rules.
  • Resolution is 71%, the healthcare call center first-call resolution average SQM Group reports from post-call surveys. Swap in your own rate if you track it.
Cost Per Call Worksheet
Line How to Calculate Small Practice Multi-Site Group Health System
1. Calls handled per month Your phone report 3,000 15,000 60,000
2. FTEs needed Line 1 ÷ 630 4.8 23.8 95.2
3. Loaded labor Line 2 × $4,940 $23,712 $117,572 $470,288
4. Supervision and QA 10% of line 3 $2,371 $11,757 $47,029
5. Technology Seats × $150 $750 $3,600 $14,400
6. Space Seats × $250 $1,250 $6,000 $24,000
7. Turnover Line 2 × 40% × $10,000 ÷ 12 $1,600 $7,933 $31,733
8. Total monthly cost Lines 3–7 $29,683 $146,862 $587,450
9. Cost per call handled Line 8 ÷ line 1 $9.89 $9.79 $9.79
10. Cost per resolved call Line 9 ÷ 0.71 $13.93 $13.79 $13.79

Scale barely moves the in-house number, because nearly every line grows with headcount. The levers that change it are calls per FTE, resolution rate and turnover. Run the worksheet a second time with your peak-month volume to see how much idle capacity you carry in slow months.

In-House vs. Outsourced vs. AI Voice Agent: Where the Money Goes

Each option moves work, and the cost of that work, between the invoice and your own staff. The details below show where that shift happens for each option and for the phone technology underneath it.

In-House Staff

In-house cost is mostly payroll. Wages, benefits, desks and supervisors make up most of lines 3 through 6 in the worksheet.

Hiring adds its own cost, because a scheduler isn't productive on day one. Seasonality can add costs beyond payroll rates. If staffing is set for an average week while demand changes by the hour, teams may be short during peaks or carry idle capacity during slow weeks. Compare cost per resolved call across peak and slow months.

Outsourced Call Centers and Answering Services

Outsourced pricing depends on where agents sit and what the contract covers. Business process outsourcing (BPO) contracts usually bill by the agent-hour or per dedicated agent, so a slow week still gets billed.

Under HIPAA, any service handling protected health information must sign a business associate agreement (BAA). The HHS model agreement also covers the business associate's subcontractors.

A medical answering service usually bills per minute or per call. Plans typically include a monthly minimum, and overage rates apply above the plan.

Many services take a message and return a callback list instead of booking the visit. In that model, the outsourced call is cheap, but the resolved call happens the next morning at in-house cost.

AI Voice Agents

AI voice-agent pricing usually starts with usage, billed per minute or per call, and platform subscription and implementation fees add to it. Whether an agent costs less than staff or an outsourced team depends on two things: the share of calls it resolves without a handoff, and the in-house cost of the calls it escalates.

Escalation isn't a failure; it's part of the design. In a peer-reviewed study of conversational AI in healthcare used for pre-procedure calls, about a third of routine-use calls still needed a quick protocol-driven nurse callback, so budget staff time for those calls.

Use a nighttime call about medication refills to check the quoted workflow:

  1. Confirm whether the agent supports the patient's after-hours refill request.
  2. Check whether it collects the medication name, dosage, prescriber and pharmacy.
  3. Verify whether it creates an EHR case for clinical review through the practice's existing workflow.
  4. Test whether a red-flag symptom triggers the practice's approved decision pathway and routing to the on-call provider. Check the warm handoff with full context for identity, complaint, insurance status and triage notes.
  5. Confirm whether morning staff receives a structured task instead of a voicemail.

Assort Health runs this through real-time, bidirectional EHR integration.

Availability: during the call, the agent reads live availability.

Insurance: it checks patient insurance eligibility.

Booking or task: it writes the booking or task.

Escalation: the practice configures which call types escalate and to whom.

Two customers report these results after deploying Assort Health:

  • South Shore Orthopedics: This orthopedic practice on athenahealth had 45% of inbound calls fully resolved by the agent. Its end-of-day voicemail backlog fell from 600–1,000 to zero.
  • MDCS Dermatology: The practice doubled labor capacity across about 20,000 calls a month and saved 460 staff hours a month.

On-Premise vs. Cloud vs. AI-Powered Cloud

A Contact Center Pipeline cost model placed technology at 4–12% of operating cost and frontline labor at 68–77%, so labor dominated those scenarios. These are modeled scenarios, not survey results.

  • On-premise: Hardware and licenses are paid upfront, and maintenance adds an ongoing yearly cost. That cost is spread across every call for years.
  • Cloud contact center as a service (CCaaS): A monthly per-seat subscription replaces the capital purchase. The technology share stays small because agents still handle every call.
  • AI-powered cloud: Usage fees replace a share of agent minutes. The technology share of cost per call rises because the much larger labor line falls.

Cost Per Call vs. Cost Per Resolved Call

Cost per resolved call captures repeat work, because patients may call again when staff haven't resolved their request. The two biggest levers are AHT and first contact resolution (FCR). Shorter calls lower cost per call. Higher FCR lowers the number of calls you pay for twice.

An unresolved call can cost money at each step of this chain:

  1. Unanswered call.
  2. Redial or abandonment.
  3. Unbooked patient.
  4. Open slot.
  5. Lost visit revenue.

Each step is plausible rather than certain, since some callers redial and book. MGMA's $125 slot value gives you a ceiling for what each lost step might cost.

After deploying Assort Health, Boston Bone & Joint reports these results:

  • Call abandonment fell from 9% to 3%.
  • Outbound campaigns automatically rescheduled 53% of appointments.
  • The group absorbed the departure of two staff without backfill.

When you compare models, divide each one's cost per call by its resolution rate. Then add the staff cost of every escalated or returned call.

Hidden Costs That Never Show Up on the Invoice

The invoice shows the rate, but your total cost of ownership also includes costs that never appear on it.

  • Training: New hires need classroom time and supervised calls before they book independently. During that paid time, new hires answer few calls.
  • Turnover: After every departure, you repeat recruiting and training. HFMA cites a cost of $10,000 to $30,000 per lost employee.
  • Quality assurance (QA): Supervisors spend hours reviewing recordings and coaching on protocol, whether staff or an outside team answers.
  • Contract lock-in: Auto-renewal clauses, notice windows, and multi-year minimums turn a monthly rate into a fixed commitment.
  • Setup fees: Script builds, onboarding and professional services are often one-time charges that belong in year-one cost per call.
  • Storage and per-minute overages: Usage plans often set a capacity limit with overages.
  • AI integration and EHR connection work: Budget for interface implementation and maintenance separately from EHR program access. Epic's Vendor Services membership is $1,900 a year. athenahealth offers certified APIs free but bills proprietary endpoints by call volume.

When you price any option, check whether onboarding, workflow configuration and ongoing automated QA are included or billed separately. Assort Health includes all three with every deployment, and typical go-live is 30 to 45 days.

How Call Center Pricing Models Change What You Pay Per Call

You and the service provider agree who carries the risk of a slow month through the pricing model, and each model fits a different volume pattern.

  • Per minute: You pay for talk time. Cost follows volume closely, but long calls and minute rounding raise the effective rate.
  • Per call: You pay a flat fee per handled call. Cost is predictable per call, but the fee usually doesn't depend on whether an agent booked anything.
  • Per agent seat: You pay monthly for each licensed or dedicated agent, which is why contracts often call this per-agent pricing. This fits steady volume and penalizes seasonal troughs, when seats sit idle.
  • Hourly: You pay per agent-hour, a common structure in BPO contracts. It suits planned coverage blocks, including evenings.
  • Hybrid: A base fee covers baseline capacity, and usage charges cover peaks. This model suits practices with seasonal surges.
  • Outcome-based: You pay per result, but this model only works with a clean baseline.

Seasonal practices usually do better with models that scale down in slow months. Steady, high-volume operations can lock in per-seat or committed rates.

Assort Health sells annual contracts. Pricing is scoped to call volume, workflows automated, practice size, site count and EHR customization.

Questions to Ask Before You Compare Quotes

These questions put every quote on the same basis before you run the worksheet:

  • What monthly minimum or seat minimum applies, and what happens in a month below it?
  • What setup, implementation or script-build fees apply in year one?
  • What are the per-minute or per-call overage rates, and how is a minute rounded?
  • What integration work is required, and who pays for it?
  • Does the solution support EHR write-back for bookings, cancellations and tasks, or does it only read data?
  • Does after-hours coverage end in a booking, a message or a callback list?
  • What is the contract length, renewal term and cancellation notice period?
  • How is resolution measured, and does an abandoned call count as resolved?

TechTarget reports that contact center vendors don't agree on what counts as a resolution, so require a clear definition before comparing quotes.

Once your worksheet is filled in, test it against real calls. Book a workflow review to hear an agent handle your scheduling rules and EHR connection. You can then compare cost per resolved call with your current model.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do I Calculate Cost Per Call for My Practice?

Add every monthly operating cost for the phone function: loaded labor, supervision and QA, technology, telecom, space and turnover. Divide the total by calls handled that month. Then divide that result by your resolution rate to get cost per resolved call.

What Costs Should Be Included in Cost Per Call?

Include fixed costs such as staff wages and benefits, seat licenses, desks and supervision. Add variable costs such as per-minute telecom, AI usage fees, overages and the extra minutes complex calls take. Recruiting, training and turnover belong in the number too, even though they're easy to leave out.

Is It Cheaper to Keep Calls In-House or Outsource Them?

It depends on volume, call complexity and after-hours need. An outsourced rate can look lower because it covers billed labor only, while minimums, setup fees and next-day callbacks from message-taking stay with your staff. Compare each option's full cost divided by the calls it actually resolves. Complex specialty scheduling and EHR access usually favor in-house or automated booking.

How Do AI Voice Agents Compare to Live Agents on Cost Per Call?

Neither option is cheaper by default, because the answer turns on resolution rate and escalation cost. Published AI pricing usually covers usage only, not subscription, implementation or the staff cost of escalated calls.

A fair comparison divides each model's total cost by the calls it resolves and adds the staff cost of escalated calls. Clinical questions and red-flag symptoms route to people under the practice's routing rules.

Is 30 Calls a Day a Lot for a Call Center?

That level is typical for a medical front desk, and MGMA DataDive data show the same for primary care front desk staff. Front desk staff also check in patients and handle other tasks, so dedicated call center agents generally handle more calls per day.

What Is the 80/20 Rule in a Call Center?

The 80/20 rule means answering 80% of calls within 20 seconds. WFM Labs describes it as a long-standing industry convention for balancing staffing cost against caller wait time, not a proven optimum.

Raising the target requires more staff, while a lower target frees staff but leaves callers waiting longer.

Assort Health
AI Built for Specialty Care

Assort Health builds AI agents for the patient journey. Its team shares practical insights on patient access, scheduling, and healthcare automation.

More from Assort